Crash Count for West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill
Crashes: Collisions involving cars, bikes, and pedestrians. 1,137
All Injuries: Any injury from a reported crash. 549
Moderate: Broken bones, concussions, and other serious injuries. 150
Serious: Life-altering injuries: amputations, paralysis, severe trauma. 6
Deaths: Lives lost to traffic violence. 2
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Sep 15, 2025
Carnage in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill
Killed 2
Severe Bleeding 4
Head 3
Face 1
Severe Lacerations 2
Head 2
Concussion 2
Head 2
Whiplash 31
Neck 15
+10
Head 6
+1
Whole body 6
+1
Back 4
Chest 2
Face 1
Lower leg/foot 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Contusion/Bruise 30
Lower leg/foot 12
+7
Lower arm/hand 5
Shoulder/upper arm 4
Head 3
Abdomen/pelvis 2
Hip/upper leg 2
Chest 1
Face 1
Whole body 1
Abrasion 22
Lower leg/foot 8
+3
Face 5
Head 2
Lower arm/hand 2
Abdomen/pelvis 1
Back 1
Hip/upper leg 1
Neck 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Whole body 1
Pain/Nausea 5
Lower leg/foot 2
Back 1
Chest 1
Neck 1
Whole body 1
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Sep 15, 2025

Who’s Injuring and Killing Pedestrians in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill?

Preventable Speeding in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill School Zones

(since 2022)
Blood on the Asphalt, Silence in City Hall

Blood on the Asphalt, Silence in City Hall

West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill: Jan 1, 2022 - Jul 16, 2025

The Toll on Our Streets

No one died here this year. But the wounds keep coming. In the last twelve months, 123 people were hurt in crashes across West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill. One was left with injuries so severe they may never heal. Children, elders, workers—no one is spared. A 14-year-old bled from the head after a crash at Forest Avenue and Victory Boulevard. A cyclist, age 28, thrown and bleeding on Brighton Avenue. These are not numbers. They are lives split open by steel and speed.

The Machines That Harm

Cars and SUVs do most of the damage. In this district, they caused 1 death and 51 injuries to pedestrians since 2022. Trucks and buses added more. Bikes and mopeds—none. The pattern is clear. The danger comes heavy and fast, from behind a windshield. The city’s own data shows it. There is no mystery here. “Driver inattention/distraction” was the cause when an 82-year-old woman was killed crossing Bard Avenue at Forest Avenue.

Leadership: Action and Evasion

Local leaders have failed to act with urgency. Assembly Member Sam Pirozzolo and State Senator Andrew Lanza both voted against extending school speed zones, turning their backs on the most basic protection for children. Pirozzolo also opposed the city’s speed camera program, a tool proven to save lives. Their votes are on the record. The silence is louder than the crash. The system investigates, but the bodies keep coming.

The Path Forward

This is not fate. Every injury, every death, could have been stopped. Lower the speed limit. Expand camera enforcement. Redesign the streets so mistakes do not kill. Call your council member. Demand action. Do not wait for another child’s blood on the asphalt.

Contact your leaders. Demand safer streets.

Citations

Citations

Other Representatives

Sam Pirozzolo
Assembly Member Sam Pirozzolo
District 63
District Office:
2090 Victory Blvd., Staten Island, NY 10314
Legislative Office:
Room 531, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12248
Kamillah Hanks
Council Member Kamillah Hanks
District 49
District Office:
130 Stuyvesant Place, 6th Floor, Staten Island, NY 10301
718-556-7370
Legislative Office:
250 Broadway, Suite 1813, New York, NY 10007
212-788-6972
Andrew Lanza
State Senator Andrew Lanza
District 24
District Office:
3845 Richmond Ave. Suite 2A, Staten Island, NY 10312
Legislative Office:
Room 413, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12247
Twitter: @senatorlanza
Other Geographies

West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill sits in Staten Island, Precinct 120, District 49, AD 63, SD 24, Staten Island CB1.

See also
City Council Districts
Community Boards
State_assembly_districts
State Senate Districts

Traffic Safety Timeline for West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill

7
S 9752 Lanza votes no, opposing a bill that would improve school zone safety.

Jun 7 - Senate backs S 9752. Mt. Vernon gets green light for up to 20 school speed zones. Law aims to slow cars near kids. Most senators vote yes. A few say no. Streets may change. Danger remains for the young.

Senate Bill S 9752, sponsored by Jamaal Bailey, authorizes Mt. Vernon to launch a school speed zone demonstration program, with up to twenty zones allowed. The bill passed the Senate on June 7, 2024, during a committee vote. The matter title reads: 'Authorizes the city of Mt. Vernon to establish a school speed zone demonstration program; authorizes installation in no more than twenty school speed zones in such city.' Bailey and a majority of senators voted yes, while a handful opposed. The bill targets speeding near schools, a known threat to children and other vulnerable road users. No formal safety analyst note was provided.


7
S 8607 Pirozzolo votes no, opposing a bill that improves school zone safety.

Jun 7 - Lawmakers back speed cameras near Kingston schools. Cameras catch drivers who speed. The bill passed both chambers. It sunsets in 2029. Children and families walk safer, but the fix is temporary.

Senate Bill S 8607, titled 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of Kingston,' passed the Senate on June 6, 2024, and the Assembly on June 7, 2024. The bill, sponsored by Senator Michelle Hinchey, creates a camera program to catch speeding drivers near schools. The program ends December 31, 2029. The measure saw broad support in both chambers, but some lawmakers voted no. The bill aims to protect children and families on foot near schools, but its impact will end unless renewed. No safety analyst note was provided.


7
A 7652 Pirozzolo votes no, opposing a bill that would improve school zone safety.

Jun 7 - Assembly passes A 7652. Schenectady gets school speed cameras. Law aims to slow drivers near kids. Cameras expire in 2028. Vote split. Streets may get safer for children on foot.

Bill A 7652, titled 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of Schenectady,' passed the Assembly on June 7, 2024. The measure, sponsored by Assemblymembers Phil Steck and Angelo Santabarbara, creates a camera program to catch speeding drivers near schools. The program ends December 31, 2028. The Assembly vote saw strong support but also opposition. Steck and Santabarbara led the push. The bill's text is blunt: 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of Schenectady.' No formal safety analyst note was provided, but speed cameras have a record of reducing driver speed and protecting children walking to school.


7
S 9752 Scarcella-Spanton votes no, opposing a bill that would improve school zone safety.

Jun 7 - Senate backs S 9752. Mt. Vernon gets green light for up to 20 school speed zones. Law aims to slow cars near kids. Most senators vote yes. A few say no. Streets may change. Danger remains for the young.

Senate Bill S 9752, sponsored by Jamaal Bailey, authorizes Mt. Vernon to launch a school speed zone demonstration program, with up to twenty zones allowed. The bill passed the Senate on June 7, 2024, during a committee vote. The matter title reads: 'Authorizes the city of Mt. Vernon to establish a school speed zone demonstration program; authorizes installation in no more than twenty school speed zones in such city.' Bailey and a majority of senators voted yes, while a handful opposed. The bill targets speeding near schools, a known threat to children and other vulnerable road users. No formal safety analyst note was provided.


6
Charles Fall Opposes Hochul Delay on Safety Boosting Congestion Pricing

Jun 6 - Governor Hochul scrapped congestion pricing for Manhattan below 60th Street. The move came late. She caved to political pressure. The toll plan is paused. The city’s streets stay clogged. Vulnerable road users remain at risk. No relief. No progress.

On June 6, 2024, Governor Kathy Hochul reversed her support for Manhattan congestion pricing, indefinitely delaying tolls below 60th Street. The plan, once set to launch June 30, was halted after pressure from U.S. House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, who feared electoral fallout. The matter, described as a move to 'indefinitely delay' tolls, drew criticism for its timing and impact. Hochul’s action, punctuated by a speech echoing toll critics, left the policy in limbo. Political consultants and union leaders, including @TwuSamuelsen, noted the decision failed to win votes or resolve the issue. The MTA confirmed the program’s pause in court. With no congestion pricing, New York’s streets remain dangerous for pedestrians and cyclists. The delay means no reduction in car traffic, no new funding for transit, and no safety gains for vulnerable road users.


6
Fall Opposes NYC Payroll Tax Increase Funding Transit Projects

Jun 6 - Council members slam Hochul’s last-minute NYC tax hike to replace congestion pricing. Transit funding hangs in limbo. Liz Krueger says the tax lacks support. Riders and workers face uncertainty as lawmakers reject new burdens and demand fairer solutions.

On June 6, 2024, State Sen. Liz Krueger (District 28) and other lawmakers responded to a proposed New York City tax hike meant to replace the indefinitely postponed $15 congestion pricing tolls. The measure, debated as Bill 28, has not advanced in committee and faces strong opposition. The matter, described as 'a last-minute funding move that drew fierce opposition,' has Krueger stating, 'I think it does not have support.' Assemblyman Brian Cunningham echoed, 'No new taxes.' The proposal would raise the payroll mobility tax, already increased last year, to fund the MTA. Rep. Jerry Nadler and business groups argue the tax unfairly targets NYC, while congestion pricing would have spread costs regionally. With the legislative session ending, MTA projects remain at risk. No safety analyst has assessed the impact on vulnerable road users.


6
S 8607 Lanza votes no, opposing a bill that improves school zone safety.

Jun 6 - Lawmakers back speed cameras near Kingston schools. Cameras catch drivers who speed. The bill passed both chambers. It sunsets in 2029. Children and families walk safer, but the fix is temporary.

Senate Bill S 8607, titled 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of Kingston,' passed the Senate on June 6, 2024, and the Assembly on June 7, 2024. The bill, sponsored by Senator Michelle Hinchey, creates a camera program to catch speeding drivers near schools. The program ends December 31, 2029. The measure saw broad support in both chambers, but some lawmakers voted no. The bill aims to protect children and families on foot near schools, but its impact will end unless renewed. No safety analyst note was provided.


6
S 8607 Scarcella-Spanton votes no, opposing a bill that improves school zone safety.

Jun 6 - Lawmakers back speed cameras near Kingston schools. Cameras catch drivers who speed. The bill passed both chambers. It sunsets in 2029. Children and families walk safer, but the fix is temporary.

Senate Bill S 8607, titled 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of Kingston,' passed the Senate on June 6, 2024, and the Assembly on June 7, 2024. The bill, sponsored by Senator Michelle Hinchey, creates a camera program to catch speeding drivers near schools. The program ends December 31, 2029. The measure saw broad support in both chambers, but some lawmakers voted no. The bill aims to protect children and families on foot near schools, but its impact will end unless renewed. No safety analyst note was provided.


5
Charles Fall Criticizes Misguided Congestion Pricing Cancellation Safety Harm

Jun 5 - Governor Hochul killed congestion pricing weeks before launch. The plan would have funded subways and buses, cut car traffic, and eased city streets. Her move keeps roads clogged, transit starved, and vulnerable New Yorkers at risk.

On June 5, 2024, Governor Kathy Hochul abruptly canceled New York’s congestion pricing plan. The policy, passed by the Legislature in 2019, was set to begin within weeks. It would have charged drivers entering Manhattan’s core, raising $1 billion yearly for transit repairs and upgrades. Hochul’s decision, made without legislative action, drew sharp criticism. Jumaane Williams, NYC Public Advocate, warned of 'irreparable harm to the city.' Natasha Elder of NYPIRG said, 'Gov. Hochul's decision to delay congestion pricing tells subway and bus riders they don't rank.' Advocates like the Tri-State Transportation Campaign called for 'bold, strong leadership.' The cancellation leaves the city’s streets jammed and transit funding gutted, with no relief for those most at risk: people on foot, on bikes, and on buses.


5
Fall Criticizes DOT for Scaling Back Safety‑Boosting Bike Lanes

Jun 5 - DOT gutted its promise. Protected lanes for kids and cyclists, gone. Homeowners waved signs. Parking won. Only a short stretch gets protection. The rest: paint and sharrows. Schools left exposed. Safety traded for curbside convenience. Another promise broken. Riders pay the price.

""I expected DOT to follow through on what they committed to... They’re falling behind on their Streets Plan [bike lane construction] targets so I would expect them to want to install every bit of protected bike lane they had already committed to."" -- Charles Fall

On June 5, 2024, the Department of Transportation (DOT) reversed course on a two-year-old plan to build protected bike lanes in northeast Queens. The project, once set to connect schools with safe cycling routes, will now feature mostly unprotected lanes and sharrows along 46th Avenue. Only a small segment between Springfield Boulevard and Cloverdale Boulevard will have a protected lane in one direction. DOT cited the need to 'maintain current curbside activities,' meaning parking. Community Board 11 had opposed the original plan, and homeowners rallied with 'NO BIKE LANES' signs and an 800-signature petition. Advocates like Laura Shepard and Elizabeth Adams condemned the rollback, saying, 'We can't let politics get in the way of saving lives.' Ben Turner criticized the prioritization of parking over safety, noting most homes already have driveways. The changes leave children and cyclists exposed, undermining the city's own Streets Master Plan targets.


4
Fall Criticizes Cost Over Safety in Waste Contracts

Jun 4 - Lawmakers blasted city officials for letting trash haulers with deadly records win new contracts. Council grilled DSNY for picking low bids over safety. Victims’ lives lost in the math. Oversight weak. Dangerous firms keep rolling. Streets stay risky for all.

On June 4, 2024, the City Council held an oversight hearing on commercial waste zone implementation and contractor selection. The hearing spotlighted the Commercial Waste Zones law, which aims to cut crashes by limiting private trash haulers in each zone. Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso, author of the 2019 reform, and Council Member Shaun Abreu led the charge, questioning why companies like Cogent Waste Solutions—with poor safety records—were awarded contracts. Reynoso declared, "Saving $20 for a business is not worth five human lives." DSNY Commissioner Jessica Tisch defended the process, promising to terminate contracts after multiple at-fault fatalities. BIC Commissioner Liz Crotty admitted, "Safety is not a factor" in license denial. Lawmakers condemned the city for putting cost before safety, leaving vulnerable road users at risk.


3
Fall Questions Awarding Contracts to Unsafe Carting Firms

Jun 3 - Sanitation named a monitor for Cogent Waste Solutions after fatal crashes and hundreds of violations. Council members question why a company with such a record still hauls trash in city zones. The city’s new waste program promises stricter oversight, but danger remains.

On June 3, 2024, the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) appointed an independent monitor for Cogent Waste Solutions, a private carting firm with a deadly safety record. The move comes before the city’s new Commercial Waste Zone program launches this fall. Council Members Shaun Abreu and Sandy Nurse raised alarms, asking, 'how the city awarded a contract to a company with a history of endangering workers to begin with.' Cogent’s trucks have killed one, injured four, and racked up hundreds of violations. Despite this, DSNY allowed Cogent to win contracts in four waste zones. DSNY Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman defended the process, stating, 'Safety was absolutely one of the weighted factors,' and promised, 'there will be consequences for lack of compliance.' The oversight hearing exposes a system that lets reckless firms operate, even as new rules loom.


3
S 9718 Lanza votes no on complete streets bill, opposing improved road safety.

Jun 3 - Senate backs S 9718. Bill orders safe street design for all. Cyclists, walkers, and riders get new protections. Some senators vote no. The car’s grip loosens, but danger remains.

Senate bill S 9718, titled 'Enables safe access to public roads for all users by utilizing complete street design principles,' passed committee votes on May 28 and June 3, 2024. Primary sponsor Sean Ryan, with co-sponsors Liz Krueger, Monica Martinez, Jack M. Martins, Anthony H. Palumbo, and Julia Salazar, pushed the measure. The bill mandates street designs that protect everyone, not just drivers. Most senators voted yes, but a block of no votes showed resistance. The bill’s language centers vulnerable users. It marks a shift: streets must serve people, not just cars.


3
S 9718 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes, boosting street safety and access for everyone.

Jun 3 - Senate backs S 9718. Bill orders safe street design for all. Cyclists, walkers, and riders get new protections. Some senators vote no. The car’s grip loosens, but danger remains.

Senate bill S 9718, titled 'Enables safe access to public roads for all users by utilizing complete street design principles,' passed committee votes on May 28 and June 3, 2024. Primary sponsor Sean Ryan, with co-sponsors Liz Krueger, Monica Martinez, Jack M. Martins, Anthony H. Palumbo, and Julia Salazar, pushed the measure. The bill mandates street designs that protect everyone, not just drivers. Most senators voted yes, but a block of no votes showed resistance. The bill’s language centers vulnerable users. It marks a shift: streets must serve people, not just cars.


31
Charles Fall Opposes Misguided Turnpike Widening Safety Harm

May 31 - Governor Murphy wants to widen the Turnpike. The plan costs billions. It will flood streets with cars and trucks. Pollution will rise. Transit riders pay more. Local families breathe dirtier air. The state ignores safer, greener options. Communities suffer. The project must stop.

On May 31, 2024, Streetsblog NYC published an opinion piece opposing Governor Phil Murphy’s $10.7 billion plan to widen the New Jersey Turnpike. The project, led by the NJ Turnpike Authority, faces criticism for ignoring alternatives like mass transit, greenways, and bikeways. The article states: 'Gov. Phil Murphy wants to spend over $10 billion to widen a highway in an environmental justice community while asking transit riders to shoulder a 15 percent fare hike. That is unjust and unacceptable.' The Turnpike Authority held limited public sessions, excluded on-the-record comments, and failed to address induced demand or environmental justice. The piece urges federal agencies to reject the project, arguing it will worsen pollution, noise, and health outcomes for vulnerable residents. The author calls for investment in safer, more sustainable transportation instead.


31
Charles Fall Supports Safety Boosting 31st Avenue Bike Boulevard Plan

May 31 - DOT will turn 1.1 miles of 31st Avenue into a bike boulevard. Two-way protected lanes. One-way for cars. Painted islands. Curb extensions. Car-free plaza possible. The plan cuts car traffic. It gives space to people. Residents demand safety after deadly crashes.

On May 31, 2024, the NYC Department of Transportation announced a redesign for 31st Avenue in Astoria, Queens. The proposal, revealed by DOT Director Ted Wright, creates a 'bike boulevard' with two-way protected bike lanes from Steinway Street to Vernon Boulevard. The plan shifts the avenue to one-way car traffic, adds painted pedestrian islands, curb extensions, and may include a car-free plaza. DOT aims to reduce vehicle presence and traffic violence, responding to local advocacy after several high-profile crashes. Residents and organizers, including Alana Herlands and John Surico, voiced strong support: 'We are going to advocate for the most ambitious plan that not only adds more space for the community... but also reduces traffic violence.' Implementation is set for summer and fall, with an extension east to 51st Street planned next year.


30
Fall Criticizes DOT Delays Maintaining Dangerous Bike Lane

May 30 - A cyclist died on the Washington Bridge. His family demands the city finish the promised protected bike lane. DOT delays leave riders exposed. Advocates say working-class immigrants and delivery workers face daily danger. The city’s promises remain unkept. The calls grow louder.

On May 30, 2024, the family of Zenaido Rosas-Pinzon, killed by a driver on the Washington Bridge, demanded the Department of Transportation (DOT) complete its long-delayed protected bike lane. The DOT had pledged to convert a car lane into a two-way protected bike path by fall 2023, but the project remains unfinished. The matter centers on the urgent need for safe cycling infrastructure: 'It's a crowded route, people are coming to and from work. It’s necessary to have a lane that is especially for the bikes,' said Cruz Rosas-Ponzon. Advocacy groups, including Transportation Alternatives, and delivery worker organizations highlight the deadly risk for working-class immigrants and deliveristas. DOT spokesman Vin Barone claims progress, but delays persist. The family’s demand is clear: finish the lane, prevent more deaths.


29
Sedan Turns Into E-Bike, Rider Injured

May 29 - Sedan turned improperly from parking on Victory Boulevard. Struck e-bike rider going straight. Rider suffered fractured knee and leg. Driver error marked the crash. Urban danger, sharp and clear.

According to the police report, a sedan started from parking and turned improperly on Victory Boulevard in Staten Island, colliding with an e-bike traveling straight. The e-bike rider, a 41-year-old man, was injured with fractures and dislocations to his knee, lower leg, and foot. The report lists 'Turning Improperly' as the primary contributing factor, highlighting driver error. The sedan sustained damage to its left side doors. No contributing factors were attributed to the e-bike rider. The crash underscores the risk posed by improper vehicle turns to vulnerable road users.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4728642 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-19
28
S 9718 Lanza votes yes, boosting street safety and access for everyone.

May 28 - Senate backs S 9718. Bill orders safe street design for all. Cyclists, walkers, and riders get new protections. Some senators vote no. The car’s grip loosens, but danger remains.

Senate bill S 9718, titled 'Enables safe access to public roads for all users by utilizing complete street design principles,' passed committee votes on May 28 and June 3, 2024. Primary sponsor Sean Ryan, with co-sponsors Liz Krueger, Monica Martinez, Jack M. Martins, Anthony H. Palumbo, and Julia Salazar, pushed the measure. The bill mandates street designs that protect everyone, not just drivers. Most senators voted yes, but a block of no votes showed resistance. The bill’s language centers vulnerable users. It marks a shift: streets must serve people, not just cars.


23
SUV Driver Falls Asleep, Overturns on Staten Island

May 23 - A 46-year-old male driver fell asleep behind the wheel, causing his SUV to overturn on Brighton Avenue. He suffered whiplash and full-body injuries but was not ejected. The crash exposed the deadly risk of driver fatigue in NYC streets.

According to the police report, a 46-year-old male driver operating a 2011 Toyota SUV on Brighton Avenue in Staten Island fell asleep while driving eastbound at 10:15 p.m. The vehicle, traveling straight ahead, overturned after the driver lost control. The point of impact was the center front end of the SUV. The driver, who was wearing a lap belt, sustained injuries to his entire body, including whiplash, but was not ejected from the vehicle. The report explicitly cites 'Fell Asleep' as the primary contributing factor to the crash. This incident highlights the critical danger of driver fatigue, a systemic hazard on city roads. No pedestrian or cyclist was involved, and no victim behaviors were listed as contributing factors.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4727293 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-19