Crash Count for Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills
Crashes: Collisions involving cars, bikes, and pedestrians. 639
All Injuries: Any injury from a reported crash. 306
Moderate: Broken bones, concussions, and other serious injuries. 79
Serious: Life-altering injuries: amputations, paralysis, severe trauma. 3
Deaths: Lives lost to traffic violence. 4
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Sep 13, 2025
Carnage in Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills
Killed 4
Severe Lacerations 2
Head 2
Concussion 2
Chest 1
Whole body 1
Whiplash 13
Neck 7
+2
Back 2
Head 2
Lower arm/hand 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Whole body 1
Contusion/Bruise 11
Lower leg/foot 6
+1
Head 2
Hip/upper leg 1
Neck 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Whole body 1
Abrasion 9
Head 3
Lower leg/foot 3
Lower arm/hand 2
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Whole body 1
Pain/Nausea 10
Head 3
Lower leg/foot 2
Back 1
Face 1
Lower arm/hand 1
Neck 1
Whole body 1
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Sep 13, 2025

Who’s Injuring and Killing Pedestrians in Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills?

Preventable Speeding in Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills School Zones

(since 2022)
Bay Street bleeds: four deaths, hundreds hurt, and the clock keeps going

Bay Street bleeds: four deaths, hundreds hurt, and the clock keeps going

Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills: Jan 1, 2022 - Aug 25, 2025

Bay Street is the spine, and it breaks.

  • Since 2022, this neighborhood logged 4 deaths and 306 injuries in 638 crashes. Heavy rigs were in 9 pedestrian injury cases; cars and SUVs in 60. A bus killed once. The tally is cold. The pain is local (NYC Open Data rollup).

  • The worst hours here spike at noon, 1 p.m., 3 p.m., and 7 p.m. People are out. So are drivers. The body count rises with the sun and again before dark (hourly distribution).

Bay Street: impact after impact

  • On July 5, a 34‑year‑old motorcyclist died at Bay and Norwood. The SUV was making a U‑turn. The bike was passing. The factor listed: unsafe speed (crash 4825308).
  • On June 11, a 24‑year‑old motorcyclist was hurt at Bay and Wave. The data names following too closely and improper passing (crash 4820153).
  • On Dec. 15, 2022, a 69‑year‑old man was struck by a bus at Bay and Canal and died. The bus was slowing. The record lists pedestrian error/confusion. He did not go home (crash 4591710).

Two Bay Street hotspots sit in the logs: Bay St and Bay Street. The names repeat. So do the sirens.

The pattern: speed, turns, and heavy metal

  • In these blocks, “unsafe speed,” “failure to yield,” and “aggressive driving” all appear in the city’s list of contributing factors. Unsafe speed is in the death file above. It is also in the neighborhood totals (small‑area factors).
  • Trucks and buses are small in number but big in harm. They show up in 9 pedestrian injury cases and one pedestrian death. They do not flinch when they hit you (vehicle rollup).

In the last 12 months, this area recorded 2 deaths and 116 injuries across 185 crashes, nearly double last year’s injuries over the same span. The curve is headed the wrong way (period stats).

Kids on small wheels, buses on big ones

  • On Aug. 5, a 13‑year‑old on a moped hit an MTA bus at Castleton and Park around 1 a.m. He was thrown and suffered severe head injuries. “The moped went through a stop sign without stopping and hit the bus,” the MTA said through press. No arrests. The Highway Squad is investigating (amNY, ABC7).

  • June 29 in Westerleigh, 16‑year‑old Nacere Ellis, on an electric scooter, collided with a westbound SUV and died. Head trauma. No charges at publication. The Highway Squad took the case (The Brooklyn Paper).

“Speed cameras have cut speeding by over 60% in locations where installed,” the State Senate wrote in a past release, cited by advocates again and again (NYS Senate).

What would stop the bleeding here?

  • Start with the corners. Daylight the crosswalks. Harden the turns. Give walkers a head start. Bay at Canal. Bay at Norwood. Bay at Wave. These are the names in the files (top intersections).
  • Slow the corridor. The logs tie deaths and injuries to unsafe speed and bad turns. Speed humps, narrowed lanes, and refuge islands cut impact speed when drivers miss. They always miss somewhere (contributing factors).
  • Keep the biggest vehicles in check. Focus enforcement and routing on trucks and buses where the records show harm. The rollup puts them in the worst outcomes here (vehicle rollup).

Citywide, two levers exist now.

  • The City can set lower speeds. Albany passed a law letting NYC drop limits on local streets. Advocates want it used. Our own guide presses for a default 20 mph and lists how to call and email to demand it (Take Action).
  • The Legislature is moving on repeat speeders. The Senate advanced S4045, to force speed‑limiting tech on drivers who rack up violations. Senator Jessica Scarcella‑Spanton voted yes in committee on June 11 and 12 (Open States file S 4045).

Fewer names should end up in these logs. The tools sit on the table. Use them.

Politics won’t hide the data

When Albany voted to renew 24/7 school‑zone cameras this June, some city lawmakers fought it. A dozen were called out by name for opposing a program that cuts speeding where it runs (Streetsblog NYC). Others backed it. The votes are public. The crash map is, too.

“Your calls are working! Call all day. Don’t stop,” urged street‑safety organizers pressing lawmakers to protect these tools (Transportation Alternatives).

Take one step today. Ask City Hall to drop the speed limit and back the bill to rein in repeat speeders. Start here: Take Action.

Citations

Citations

Other Representatives

Charles Fall
Assembly Member Charles Fall
District 61
District Office:
250 Broadway 22nd Floor Suite 2203, New York, NY 10007
Legislative Office:
Room 729, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12248
Twitter: @Charlesdfall
Kamillah Hanks
Council Member Kamillah Hanks
District 49
District Office:
130 Stuyvesant Place, 6th Floor, Staten Island, NY 10301
718-556-7370
Legislative Office:
250 Broadway, Suite 1813, New York, NY 10007
212-788-6972
Jessica Scarcella-Spanton
State Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton
District 23
District Office:
2875 W. 8th St. Unit #3, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Legislative Office:
Room 617, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12247
Other Geographies

Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills sits in Staten Island, Precinct 120, District 49, AD 61, SD 23, Staten Island CB1.

See also
City Council Districts
Community Boards
State_assembly_districts
State Senate Districts

Traffic Safety Timeline for Tompkinsville-Stapleton-Clifton-Fox Hills

11
Int 1304-2025 Hanks co-sponsors bill requiring micromobility share systems to display safety rules.

Jun 11 - Council bill orders bike and scooter share firms to show road rules at docks and in apps. Riders must review rules yearly. No extra fees. Aim: clear, visible reminders. Committee review underway.

Bill Int 1304-2025 sits with the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure after introduction on June 11, 2025. The bill, titled "A Local Law to amend the administrative code...requiring micromobility share system operators to display rules of the road for safe operation," demands operators post rules at stations and in apps. Riders must review these rules at least once a year before unlocking a device. The law bars operators from charging for the review time. Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers leads as primary sponsor, joined by Hanif, Brewer, Restler, Louis, Narcisse, Lee, Marte, Hanks, Banks, Gutiérrez, Ariola, and Morano. The measure aims for clear, accessible safety information but does not address street design or enforcement.


11
S 7678 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes to expand school speed cameras, boosting pedestrian safety.

Jun 11 - White Plains gets speed cameras near schools. Lawmakers move fast. Most vote yes. Cameras catch drivers who endanger kids. Program ends 2030. Streets may slow. Danger faces children every day.

Senate Bill S 7678, sponsored by Shelley Mayer, establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in White Plains. The bill passed the Senate on June 11, 2025, and the Assembly on June 16, 2025. The matter reads: 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the city of White Plains; repeals authorization of program December 31, 2030.' Mayer led the push. Most senators and assembly members voted yes. The bill aims to catch speeding drivers near schools, a known threat to children and families. No safety analyst note was provided.


11
S 7785 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes to weaken bus rules, increasing pedestrian and cyclist risk.

Jun 11 - Senate passed S 7785. The bill carves out large Mitchell-Lama housing from bus traffic rules. Lawmakers voted yes. The carve-out weakens enforcement. Streets grow less safe for people on foot and bike.

Bill S 7785, titled 'Relates to bus operation-related traffic regulations,' passed the Senate and Assembly in June 2025. The measure, sponsored by Senator Jamaal Bailey, excludes violations in cooperative housing developments with at least 10,000 Mitchell-Lama units from bus operation traffic regulations. The bill advanced through committee and received broad support in both chambers. By exempting these large complexes, the law weakens traffic enforcement where thousands live. This move increases risk to pedestrians and cyclists, stripping away protections that save lives. Vulnerable road users lose another layer of safety in dense city streets.


10
Fall Supports Safety Boosting Third Avenue Complete Street Extension

Jun 10 - Third Avenue will lose car lanes. A protected bike lane and bus lane will take their place. Pedestrian islands and wider sidewalks will rise. Community Board 6 backed the plan. The city aims to calm deadly traffic and give space to people.

On June 10, 2025, the Department of Transportation unveiled its plan to extend the Third Avenue Complete Street project from E. 59th to E. 24th Street. The proposal, approved unanimously by Community Board 6's Transportation Committee, removes car lanes for a protected bike lane, a dedicated bus lane, and pedestrian improvements. The DOT will install parking-protected bike lanes, painted sidewalk extensions, and pedestrian islands. The official matter summary states: 'The proposal will reduce the roadway from six or seven lanes for cars to three moving lanes, two parking lanes, plus a bus lane and a bike lane.' DOT Project Manager Esteban Doyle said the plan reallocates space to match actual use. Community members praised the move. The safety analyst notes: 'The event text does not specify what design was implemented or how it affected pedestrians and cyclists, so no safety impact can be determined.' Installation is set for summer or fall 2025.


10
S 8117 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes on school speed cameras, boosting safety for children.

Jun 10 - Senate backs S 8117. Oneida County gets school speed zone cameras. Law sunsets in 2030. Lawmakers act. Streets near schools may slow. Children walk safer. Drivers face new eyes.

Senate bill S 8117, titled 'Establishes a school speed zone camera demonstration program in the county of Oneida,' passed committee votes on May 27 and June 10, 2025. The bill, sponsored by Senator Joseph A. Griffo (District 53), sets up speed cameras near schools in Oneida County. The program ends December 31, 2030. The Senate voted yes, with only two no votes and several excused. The measure aims to slow drivers near schools and protect children. No safety analyst note was provided. The bill now moves forward in the legislative process.


9
Charles Fall Supports Safety Boosting Flatbush Center Running Bus Lane

Jun 9 - DOT wants a center-running bus lane on Flatbush Avenue. Council members back it. The plan could cut car lanes, add bus islands, and calm deadly traffic. The mayor must decide. Pedestrians and riders wait. The street’s future hangs in the balance.

On June 9, 2025, Streetsblog NYC reported the NYC DOT’s proposal for a center-running bus lane on Flatbush Avenue from Grand Army Plaza to Livingston Street. The plan, supported by Council Members Lincoln Restler, Shahana Hanif, Crystal Hudson, and Rita Joseph, aims to improve transit and pedestrian safety. The matter summary states: 'A proposed center-running bus lane on Flatbush Avenue... is being considered by the NYC Department of Transportation (DOT) as a way to improve transit, calm traffic, and enhance pedestrian safety.' The project faces delays and political pushback, including the removal of a protected bike lane after developer objections. A safety analyst notes: 'Center-running bus lanes typically reduce conflicts between buses, cars, pedestrians, and cyclists, calm traffic, and can enable street redesigns that improve safety and comfort for vulnerable road users.' The DOT will present a detailed plan in the fall. The final decision rests with Mayor Adams.


9
S 915 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes, boosting street safety and access for everyone.

Jun 9 - Senate passes S 915. Bill demands safe roads for all. Complete street design at its core. Cyclists, walkers, and riders get a fighting chance. Vote split, but the message is clear: streets must serve people, not just cars.

Senate Bill S 915, titled 'Enables safe access to public roads for all users by utilizing complete street design principles,' passed committee on June 9, 2025. The bill, sponsored by Sean Ryan (District 61) with co-sponsors Joseph P. Addabbo Jr., Samra Brouk, Leroy Comrie, Patricia Fahy, Pete Harckham, Robert Jackson, Liz Krueger, and Christopher Ryan, pushes for roads built for everyone. The Senate voted, with most in favor and a block opposed. The bill's language is blunt: roads must be safe for all, not just drivers. No safety analyst note was provided, but the intent is clear—prioritize vulnerable road users in every street plan.


28
E-Bike Rider Injured in Bay Street Truck Collision

May 28 - A truck and e-bike collided on Bay Street. The e-bike rider took the hit, chest injured, internal pain. Police say traffic control was ignored. The truck rolled west. The e-bike moved south. The street stayed hard and unforgiving.

A collision between a Hino truck and an e-bike occurred at 596 Bay Street in Staten Island. The crash left a 51-year-old male e-bike rider injured, suffering chest and internal injuries. According to the police report, 'Traffic Control Disregarded' was listed as a contributing factor. The truck was traveling west, the e-bike south. The truck driver and another occupant were not reported injured. The e-bike rider was wearing a helmet. No blame is assigned to the injured cyclist. The data highlights a failure to obey traffic controls, a systemic danger for vulnerable road users.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4817382 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-17
28
Sedan Backs Into Elderly Pedestrian on Vanderbilt

May 28 - A sedan reversed on Vanderbilt Avenue. The driver failed to see an 86-year-old man. The car struck him. His arm broke. He went into shock. Police blamed unsafe backing and distraction. The street stayed quiet. The damage was done.

An 86-year-old pedestrian suffered a fractured arm and shock after being struck by a sedan backing up near 75 Vanderbilt Avenue in Staten Island. According to the police report, the driver was reversing when the collision occurred. The report lists 'Backing Unsafely' and 'Driver Inattention/Distraction' as contributing factors. The pedestrian was not in the roadway at the time of the crash. No other serious injuries were reported among vehicle occupants. The vehicle sustained no damage. The crash highlights the danger posed when drivers reverse without full attention, especially near vulnerable road users.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4816577 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-17
28
Int 1288-2025 Hanks co-sponsors discounted senior bike share bill, boosting street safety.

May 28 - Council bill pushes for discounted bike share rates for New Yorkers 65 and up. The move aims to open city streets to older riders. The measure sits with the Transportation Committee. No safety review yet.

Int 1288-2025 was introduced on May 28, 2025, and referred to the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. The bill would require the Department of Transportation to set a discounted bike share rate for seniors, defined as those 65 or older. The matter title reads: 'A Local Law to amend the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to a discounted bike share rate for seniors.' Council Member Farah N. Louis leads as primary sponsor, joined by Marte, Powers, Lee, Nurse, Hanif, Brewer, Banks, Menin, Feliz, Hanks, Avilés, and Gutiérrez. The bill was re-referred to committee on June 4, 2025. No safety analyst has yet assessed its impact on vulnerable road users.


28
Int 1288-2025 Hanks co-sponsors senior bike share discount bill, boosting street safety.

May 28 - Council pushes a bill to cut bike share costs for New Yorkers over 65. The measure aims to open city cycling to more seniors. The committee now weighs its next move.

Bill Int 1288-2025, now in the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, was introduced May 28, 2025. The bill, titled 'A Local Law to amend the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to a discounted bike share rate for seniors,' would require the Department of Transportation to mandate lower bike share rates for those 65 and older. Council Member Farah N. Louis leads as primary sponsor, joined by Marte, Powers, Lee, Nurse, Hanif, Brewer, Banks, Menin, Feliz, Hanks, Avilés, Gutiérrez, and Restler. The bill was re-referred to committee June 4. The move aims to make cycling more accessible for older New Yorkers.


20
Fall Opposes Cuomo Mayoral Bid Amid Transit Divide

May 20 - Citi Bike workers back Brad Lander for mayor. Their bosses at Lyft fund Andrew Cuomo’s PAC. The split exposes fault lines in city transit. Riders and workers watch. Streets remain dangerous. The fight for safer roads grinds on.

On May 20, 2025, Citi Bike workers endorsed Brad Lander for mayor, as reported by Streetsblog NYC. The article states: “Citi Bike's workers are backing Brad Lander for mayor while their bosses at Lyft chip in on Andrew Cuomo's PAC.” This is not a council bill, but a political endorsement. Local 320 President Edwin Aviles called Lander 'the one and only person in NYC government who has ever publicly recognized and championed safety, fair wages, and a fair Collective Bargaining Agreement.' No council member sponsored or voted on this action. The endorsement signals a push for leadership that may prioritize safer streets and better conditions for cyclists and pedestrians. According to safety analysts, this event concerns political endorsements and campaign contributions, not a policy or legislative change affecting pedestrian or cyclist safety.


12
Driver Rams Police, Fires Through Windshield

May 12 - A man in a Nissan crashed into a police car on Staten Island. He fired a gun through his windshield. Officers dodged the bullet but landed in the hospital, cut by glass. Police found two guns. The driver was arrested.

According to the New York Post (May 12, 2025), a 31-year-old man fled a traffic stop on Staten Island, crashed his Nissan SUV into a police cruiser, and fired a gun through his own windshield, striking the vehicle but missing the officers. The article states, “The gunman smashed his Nissan into the police car and then opened fire on the vehicle, striking it but missing the officers inside.” Officers were hospitalized for injuries from shattered glass. Police recovered two guns from the vehicle. The suspect, on parole for a prior assault, was arrested at the scene. The incident highlights the dangers of high-speed flight and armed confrontations during routine traffic enforcement.


6
Fall Supports Safety Boosting Protected Bike Lane Expansion

May 6 - Mayoral hopefuls vow to overhaul city streets. They promise more protected bike lanes, daylighting, and bus lanes. Each pledges to close deadly gaps and enforce Vision Zero. Their words center safety for people walking, biking, and riding transit.

On May 6, 2025, Streetsblog NYC published 'Decision 2025: Mayoral Candidates Answer Our Question 3.' The piece asked candidates how they would make streets safer for walking and biking. Scott Stringer, Zellnor Myrie, Jessica Ramos, Brad Lander, and Zohran Mamdani all responded. Stringer highlighted his push for protected bike lanes and daylighting. Myrie promised to meet or exceed the Streets Master Plan’s 50-mile annual bike lane goal and to end delays. Ramos pledged 200 miles of physically separated bike lanes and to close network gaps. Lander committed to the Streets Master Plan and fixing greenway connections. Mamdani vowed to use all mayoral powers for Vision Zero. Each candidate supports redesigning streets to protect vulnerable road users. Their plans focus on proven changes—protected lanes, pedestrian islands, daylighting, and bus lanes—to cut injuries and deaths.


6
S 4804 Scarcella-Spanton votes yes to create safety zones, improving street safety for all.

May 6 - Senate backs S 4804. The bill sets first responder safety zones and lowers speed limits. Lawmakers move to shield workers on chaotic streets. The vote is swift. The intent is clear. Danger zones get new rules.

Senate bill S 4804, titled 'Relates to establishing first responder safety zones and setting speed limits in such safety zones,' passed committee on April 29, 2025, and cleared the full Senate on May 6, 2025. Sponsored by Senator Christopher Ryan (District 50) with co-sponsors Joseph P. Addabbo Jr., Pamela Helming, Robert Rolison, and William Weber, the bill aims to carve out protected zones for first responders and enforce lower speed limits in those areas. The measure won broad support, with nearly all senators voting yes. The bill targets the chaos and risk drivers pose to workers and bystanders at emergency scenes. No safety analyst note was provided.


5
Left Turn on Broad Street Injures Driver

May 5 - Two sedans collided at Broad and Gordon. One driver suffered arm injuries. Police cite failure to yield. Metal struck metal. Streets stayed dangerous.

Two sedans crashed at Broad Street and Gordon Street in Staten Island. One driver, a 26-year-old woman, was injured in the arm and reported whiplash. According to the police report, the crash involved a left turn and was caused by 'Failure to Yield Right-of-Way.' The report lists this driver error for both vehicles. Airbags deployed in at least one car. No pedestrians or cyclists were involved. The collision left one person hurt and highlighted the risk at this intersection.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4810928 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-17
1
Int 0193-2024 Hanks votes yes on taxi dooring warning decals, no major safety change.

May 1 - Council passes law. Taxis and for-hire cars must post bold warnings on rear doors. Riders face the message: look for cyclists before swinging the door. A move to cut dooring. City acts. Cyclists stay in the crosshairs.

Int 0193-2024, now law, cleared the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure and passed City Council on May 1, 2025. The bill, titled 'A Local Law...requiring taxis and for-hire vehicles to display a decal warning passengers to look for cyclists when opening the door,' demands clear warning signs on all rear passenger doors. Lincoln Restler led as primary sponsor, joined by Gutiérrez, Hudson, Rivera, Won, and others. The Taxi and Limousine Commission must provide decals at no cost. The law aims to fight dooring, a threat to cyclists citywide. Enacted May 31, 2025, it takes effect in 120 days.


22
E-Scooter Rider Hurt in Park Hill Crash

Apr 22 - E-scooter slammed headfirst on Park Hill Lane. Rider, 32, suffered head injury. Police cite failure to yield. Streets stay ruthless for the vulnerable.

A 32-year-old e-scooter rider was injured on Park Hill Lane, Staten Island. According to the police report, the crash involved a left-turning e-scooter and another vehicle. The rider suffered a head injury and was in shock. Police list 'Failure to Yield Right-of-Way' as a contributing factor. No helmet use was noted. The crash highlights the ongoing danger faced by those outside cars on city streets.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4808020 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-09-17
10
Int 1105-2024 Hanks misses vote on bill boosting street safety accountability.

Apr 10 - Council passed a law forcing DOT to post sharp, regular updates on street safety projects. Progress on bike lanes, bus lanes, and signals must go public. No more hiding delays or cost overruns. The city must show its work.

Bill Int 1105-2024, now enacted, came through the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. Introduced November 13, 2024, it passed Council on April 10, 2025, and became law May 10, 2025. The bill's title: 'A Local Law to amend the administrative code...in relation to tracking progress made towards the requirements of the streets master plan.' Council Member Julie Won led sponsorship, joined by Brooks-Powers, Hanif, Ayala, and others. The law demands DOT post annual and monthly updates on every project tied to the master plan—listing details, timelines, funding, and setbacks. This law brings sunlight to street safety work, making the city answer for every mile and missed deadline.


9
Fall Opposes Harmful Federal Effort To Halt Congestion Pricing

Apr 9 - Federal lawyers bark. The MTA stands firm. The U.S. DOT demands New York end congestion pricing by April 20. The state refuses. Threats fly. No action lands. Meanwhile, Manhattan streets see fewer crashes, faster buses, and more people on foot.

On April 9, 2025, federal lawyers told Judge Lewis Liman that the U.S. Department of Transportation still demands New York stop congestion pricing by April 20. The case, rooted in the MTA’s lawsuit against the feds, remains unresolved. The DOT’s attorney, Dominika Tarczynska, said, "The Department of Transportation maintains the position that New York City should stop charging tolls by April 20." MTA attorney Robert Kaplan countered, "Congestion pricing is in effect, we believe it's working, and ... we don't intend to turn it off unless there's an order from your honor." Governor Hochul and the MTA refuse to comply. The federal government threatens vague consequences but takes no concrete steps. The MTA’s November agreement with the Biden-era DOT did not allow for unilateral federal withdrawal. As the legal fight drags on, congestion pricing continues. Streets south of 60th Street see fewer crashes. Bus speeds rise. Foot traffic grows. Vulnerable road users benefit while politicians bicker.