Crash Count for Windsor Terrace-South Slope
Crashes: Collisions involving cars, bikes, and pedestrians. 610
All Injuries: Any injury from a reported crash. 332
Moderate: Broken bones, concussions, and other serious injuries. 51
Serious: Life-altering injuries: amputations, paralysis, severe trauma. 2
Deaths: Lives lost to traffic violence. 0
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Nov 5, 2025
Carnage in Windsor Terrace-South Slope
Detailed breakdowns aren’t yet available for this year slice; totals below reflect the selected window.
Severe Lacerations 1
Lower leg/foot 1
Concussion 1
Head 1
Whiplash 9
Neck 7
+2
Head 1
Lower leg/foot 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Contusion/Bruise 9
Head 4
Abdomen/pelvis 3
Lower leg/foot 2
Lower arm/hand 1
Abrasion 13
Lower leg/foot 4
Lower arm/hand 3
Whole body 2
Face 1
Head 1
Hip/upper leg 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Pain/Nausea 7
Head 2
Abdomen/pelvis 1
Chest 1
Lower arm/hand 1
Neck 1
Shoulder/upper arm 1
Data from Jan 1, 2022 to Nov 5, 2025

Who’s Injuring and Killing Pedestrians in Windsor Terrace-South Slope?

Preventable Speeding in Windsor Terrace-South Slope School Zones

(since 2022)

Caught Speeding Recently in Windsor Terrace-South Slope

Vehicles – Caught Speeding in NYC (12 months)
  1. 2025 Blue Acura Sedan (KXH4599) – 50 times • 1 in last 90d here
  2. 2016 White Lexus Suburban (LNC2044) – 36 times • 1 in last 90d here
  3. 2016 White Jeep Suburban (LKR1028) – 31 times • 1 in last 90d here
  4. 2023 Black Acura Suburban (LBJ8017) – 30 times • 1 in last 90d here
  5. 2024 Land Rover Station Wagon (KVH2364) – 29 times • 1 in last 90d here

One Broken Body at a Time—Windsor Terrace Bleeds, Leaders Stall

Windsor Terrace-South Slope: Jan 1, 2022 - Jul 17, 2025

The Toll in Plain Sight

The streets of Windsor Terrace-South Slope do not forgive. In the past twelve months, 73 people have been injured in 115 crashes. One was left with serious injuries. No one died, but the numbers do not tell the whole story. Each bruise, each broken bone, is a life changed. Injuries cut across every age group. Children, adults, the old—all marked by the same violence.

On May 27, a 28-year-old cyclist was hit at 7th Avenue and 19th Street. The crash left him with a head injury. The cause: failure to yield. The car kept going straight. The bike kept going straight. Only one body broke. NYC Open Data

The Human Cost

The numbers pile up. Since 2022, 249 people have been injured in 430 crashes here. Two were serious. No deaths, but the luck will not hold. Most injuries come from cars and SUVs—14 pedestrian injuries in three years. Trucks and buses hurt three. Bikes and mopeds, three more. The street does not care who you are.

A cyclist, age 60, was left with severe face wounds after being hit by a sedan on Greenwood Avenue this May. Another cyclist, 23, suffered deep cuts to his leg after a bike-on-bike crash on Prospect Park Southwest. The pain is not abstract. It is flesh and blood.

Leaders: Words and Silence

Local leaders have spoken, but action is slow. State Senator Zellnor Myrie rode a bike through Brooklyn and said the city should make cycling as easy and safe as possible for everyone. Council Member Shahana Hanif is “exploring” ways to restore civil summonses for cyclists, after police kept ticketing them for legal riding. But the streets remain the same.

Bills to force repeat speeders to slow down sit in Albany. Local leaders have co-sponsored some, missed votes on others. The violence continues.

What Comes Next

This is not fate. Every crash is preventable. Every injury is a failure of will. Call your council member. Call your senator. Demand a 20 mph speed limit. Demand real enforcement against repeat speeders. Do not wait for the first death.

Citations

Citations

Other Representatives

Robert Carroll
Assembly Member Robert Carroll
District 44
District Office:
416 7th Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11215
Legislative Office:
Room 557, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12248
Shahana Hanif
Council Member Shahana Hanif
District 39
District Office:
456 5th Avenue, 3rd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11215
718-499-1090
Legislative Office:
250 Broadway, Suite 1745, New York, NY 10007
212-788-6969
Zellnor Myrie
State Senator Zellnor Myrie
District 20
District Office:
1077 Nostrand Ave. Ground Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Legislative Office:
Room 806, Legislative Office Building, Albany, NY 12247
Twitter: @zellnor4ny
Other Geographies

Windsor Terrace-South Slope Windsor Terrace-South Slope sits in Brooklyn, Precinct 72, District 39, AD 44, SD 20, Brooklyn CB7.

See also
Boroughs
City Council Districts
Community Boards
State_assembly_districts
State Senate Districts

Traffic Safety Timeline for Windsor Terrace-South Slope

9
School Bus Slams Fence In Brooklyn

Apr 9 - A school bus tore through a fence in Ditmas Park. An eight-year-old boy and his mother took the brunt. Broken arm. Head and neck wounds. The bus mounted the sidewalk, iron twisted, cinderblock shattered. The driver stayed. The street stayed dangerous.

CBS New York reported on April 9, 2025, that a school bus crashed into a fence at Bedford Avenue and Farragut Road in Brooklyn, injuring an 8-year-old boy and his 43-year-old mother. The article quotes Councilmember Farrah Louis: "It appeared the driver was driving and hit the gas instead of the brakes, trying to avoid another car, and that's how he crashed." No students were on the bus at the time. The victims were hospitalized with serious injuries. Witnesses described the bus waiting for a pedestrian before suddenly jumping the curb and smashing through the fence. The incident highlights ongoing traffic dangers in the area and raises questions about driver error and the need for improved street safety.


3
Hanif Supports Safety Boosting Ashland Place Bike Lane

Apr 3 - Brooklyn’s Ashland Place stays deadly. DOT delays a promised bike lane. Elected officials and residents demand action. Private interests block progress. Cyclists face crashes and fear. The city shrugs. The gap remains. Lives hang in the balance.

On April 3, 2025, a coalition of Brooklyn officials—including Council Members Crystal Hudson, Shahana Hanif, Lincoln Restler, Assembly Members Andrew Gounardes, Jo Anne Simon, Phara Souffrant Forrest, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, and Borough President Antonio Reynoso—sent a letter urging DOT to finish the protected bike lane on Ashland Place. The letter called the block a 'missing link in Brooklyn’s protected bike lane network.' Brooklyn Community Board 2 backed the demand. DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez and Borough Commissioner Keith Bray offered only vague replies. The block’s exclusion traces to a mayoral advisor’s intervention for developer Two Trees. Advocates like Kathy Park Price slammed the city: 'Private interests are able to redesign our streets, prioritizing vehicles over safety at a critical corridor.' Despite unanimous support, DOT keeps the street dangerous. The city’s inaction leaves cyclists exposed and the community frustrated.


2
Brooklyn Crash Leaves Family Scarred, Three Dead

Apr 2 - A car plowed through families on Ocean Parkway. Three killed. Survivors hurt, shaken, haunted. The driver had a suspended license, dozens of violations, unpaid fines. The city’s streets failed to protect the most vulnerable. Pain lingers. Justice waits.

ABC7 reported on April 2, 2025, that a crash in Brooklyn killed a mother and her two daughters, leaving another family injured and traumatized. The article states, “Shakhzod described ongoing back pain and fears of another accident.” The driver, Miriam Yarimi, had 93 violations, $10,000 in unpaid fines, and a suspended license. She struck an Uber, then hit families crossing Ocean Parkway, flipping her vehicle. Yarimi faces charges including manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide. The crash exposes systemic failure: a driver with a long record remained on the road. Survivors suffer lasting physical and emotional wounds. The city’s enforcement and oversight remain under scrutiny.


2
Hanif Supports Safety Boosting Open Streets Expansion Amid Merchant Concerns

Apr 2 - Park Slope’s Open Streets plan hangs in the balance. Merchants split. Some cheer crowds and sales. Others fear ruin. Council Member Hanif and Community Board 6 gather voices. DOT holds the final word. Compromise and conflict shape Fifth Avenue’s future.

Council Member Shahana Hanif (District 39) and Community Board 6 launched a survey on April 2, 2025, to collect resident and merchant feedback on the Park Slope Open Streets program. The matter, titled 'Merchants call for compromise as Park Slope Open Streets program faces scrutiny,' centers on the proposed closure of Fifth Avenue every Saturday from May to October. Hanif’s action: gathering input and relaying concerns to the Department of Transportation (DOT) before a final decision. The survey showed strong public support—455 out of 489 respondents favored the program—but merchant opinions split. Some praised increased foot traffic and sales; others reported steep losses. Critics cited business access, traffic, and e-bike safety. Merchants petitioned Hanif and DOT for a thorough review and recovery plan. Community Board 6’s Mike Racioppo recommended proper funding and expansion. The DOT has not yet ruled. The debate spotlights the tension between public space and business survival.


1
Hanif Supports Safety Boosting Stop Super Speeders Bill

Apr 1 - After a crash killed a mother and two daughters in Gravesend, advocates and Council Member Shahana Hanif rallied for the Stop Super Speeders bill. The law would force repeat reckless drivers to use speed-limiting tech. Survivors demand action. Lawmakers promise change.

On April 1, 2025, Council Member Shahana Hanif joined a rally at Brooklyn Borough Hall demanding passage of the Stop Super Speeders bill. The bill, sponsored in Albany by State Sen. Andrew Gounardes and Assemblymember Emily Gallagher, would require drivers with repeated violations to install intelligent speed assistance (ISA) devices. These devices cap speed at 5 mph over the limit for those with 11 or more license points in 24 months or six camera tickets in a year. The rally followed a fatal Gravesend crash that killed a mother and her two daughters. Hanif and other lawmakers called current enforcement—ticketing, suspensions, fines, jail—ineffective. Assembly Member Jo Anne Simon said, 'The speed limiter technology is available to us. Let’s use it. It will save lives.' The bill is modeled on EU and Virginia laws. Some opposition remains, but supporters say the measure is urgent and practical.


1
Myrie Urges Immediate Action on Safety Boosting Speed Bill

Apr 1 - After a crash killed a mother and two daughters in Gravesend, advocates and Council Member Shahana Hanif rallied for the Stop Super Speeders bill. The law would force repeat reckless drivers to use speed-limiting tech. Survivors demand action. Lawmakers promise change.

On April 1, 2025, Council Member Shahana Hanif joined a rally at Brooklyn Borough Hall demanding passage of the Stop Super Speeders bill. The bill, sponsored in Albany by State Sen. Andrew Gounardes and Assemblymember Emily Gallagher, would require drivers with repeated violations to install intelligent speed assistance (ISA) devices. These devices cap speed at 5 mph over the limit for those with 11 or more license points in 24 months or six camera tickets in a year. The rally followed a fatal Gravesend crash that killed a mother and her two daughters. Hanif and other lawmakers called current enforcement—ticketing, suspensions, fines, jail—ineffective. Assembly Member Jo Anne Simon said, 'The speed limiter technology is available to us. Let’s use it. It will save lives.' The bill is modeled on EU and Virginia laws. Some opposition remains, but supporters say the measure is urgent and practical.


1
Ocean Parkway Crash Exposes Deadly Pattern

Apr 1 - A mother and two children died on Ocean Parkway. A driver with a suspended license and a record of violations struck them. The road has claimed many lives before. Residents see speeding daily. Calls for change echo. Danger remains.

The New York Post (April 1, 2025) reports that Ocean Parkway in Brooklyn has seen 20 deaths since 2014, with nearly 2,400 injuries since 2012. On March 30, Miriam Yarimi, driving with a suspended license and 93 prior traffic violations, crashed into an Uber and then into a family, killing Natasha Saada and two of her children. A third child remains in critical condition. The article quotes Ben Furnas of Transportation Alternatives: Ocean Parkway is 'one of Brooklyn's most dangerous roads.' Residents and advocates demand stronger safety measures, including speed-limiting technology for repeat offenders. Mayor Eric Adams is open to lowering the speed limit, but state approval is needed. Despite Vision Zero, Ocean Parkway remains hazardous for pedestrians.


31
Brooklyn Driver Kills Mother, Two Daughters

Mar 31 - A speeding Audi struck a mother and her daughters in a Brooklyn crosswalk. The crash killed three. The youngest son was left fighting for life. The driver, with a long record of violations, now faces manslaughter charges.

According to the New York Post (March 31, 2025), Miriam Yarimi drove her Audi through a Brooklyn crosswalk, killing Natasha Saada and her daughters, Diana and Debra. Saada’s 4-year-old son was critically injured. Police said the victims were 'legally crossing the street in a crosswalk when the driver's speeding Audi struck them.' Yarimi’s car had over 93 traffic violations. She told first responders she was 'possessed' and is undergoing psychiatric evaluation. The article notes Yarimi’s history of paranoid social media posts and erratic behavior. She has been charged with manslaughter. The crash highlights persistent dangers for pedestrians and raises questions about enforcement against repeat traffic offenders.


30
Brooklyn Crash Kills Mother, Two Children

Mar 30 - A car struck a family in a Brooklyn crosswalk. A mother and two daughters died. Her young son was left in critical condition. The driver faced charges. The street showed the scars. Mourners filled the night.

The New York Times (March 30, 2025) reported a deadly crash at Ocean Parkway and Quentin Road, Brooklyn. Miriam Yarimi, driving with a suspended license, "barreled into a silver Toyota Camry" before veering into a crosswalk and hitting Natasha Saada and her children. Yarimi was charged with manslaughter, reckless driving, and other offenses. The Audi she drove had a record of 99 violations, including red-light and school-zone speeding tickets. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said, "This was a horrific tragedy caused by someone who shouldn't have been on the road." The crash highlights persistent dangers for pedestrians and ongoing issues with enforcement and accountability for repeat traffic offenders.


29
Brooklyn Crash Kills Mother, Two Children

Mar 29 - A car slammed through a Brooklyn crosswalk. A mother and two daughters died. Her young son clings to life. Metal and glass scattered. Sirens wailed. The driver, unlicensed, faces manslaughter. Ocean Parkway became a scene of sudden loss.

CBS New York reported on March 29, 2025, that a crash on Ocean Parkway killed a mother and her two daughters, ages 5 and 8, while her 4-year-old son was left in critical condition. Police say a Toyota Camry, turning right, was rear-ended by an Audi sedan. The impact pushed the Camry aside, and the Audi continued forward, striking the family in a crosswalk before overturning. The Audi's driver, Miriam Yarimi, 32, was arrested and charged with manslaughter. Police said she was driving on a suspended license. Investigators are examining whether she ran a red light or was speeding. NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said, 'This was a horrific tragedy caused by someone who shouldn't have been on the road.' The incident highlights ongoing risks for pedestrians and questions about enforcement of license suspensions.


23
E-Bike Rider Runs Stop, Kills Pedestrian

Mar 23 - Luis Cruz stepped from his car. An e-bike delivery worker sped through a stop sign. The crash was sudden. Cruz died on the street. The rider stayed. The intersection has seen this before. The system pushes speed. The danger remains.

Gothamist reported on March 23, 2025, that Luis Cruz, 49, died after an e-bike delivery worker "sped through a stop sign" and struck him as he exited his double-parked car in Greenpoint, Brooklyn. Witness Jack Collins said, "He died basically on the spot." The e-bike rider remained at the scene. No arrests were made. The article notes this intersection is known for frequent stop sign violations: "It's not a unicorn incident. It's happened a lot." The piece highlights systemic issues, including delivery app pressures and gaps in e-bike regulation. City data shows e-bikes account for less than 2% of traffic deaths, but the policy debate continues. Lawmakers have called for tighter rules, as delivery workers face incentives to rush.


10
Ambulance Right Turn Hits E-Scooter Rider

Mar 10 - An ambulance making a right turn struck a 31-year-old male e-scooter rider in Brooklyn. The rider suffered facial abrasions and was conscious at the scene. Police cited failure to yield right-of-way and unsafe speed as key factors in the crash.

According to the police report, the crash occurred at 7:09 AM near Fort Hamilton Parkway in Brooklyn. The ambulance was making a right turn when it collided with the e-scooter, which was traveling straight ahead. The e-scooter rider, a 31-year-old male wearing a helmet, sustained abrasions to his face and was conscious after the impact. The report lists 'Failure to Yield Right-of-Way' by the ambulance driver and 'Unsafe Speed' by the e-scooter rider as contributing factors. Additionally, 'Pedestrian/Bicyclist/Other Pedestrian Error/Confusion' was noted, indicating rider error but no fault was assigned to the victim. The ambulance sustained no damage, while the e-scooter showed damage to its center front end. The rider was not ejected from the vehicle.


  • Motor Vehicle Collisions – CrashID 4797846 - Crashes, Persons, Vehicles , NYC Open Data, Accessed 2025-11-09
8
Repeat Offender Kills Passenger In Brooklyn Crash

Mar 8 - A driver out on bail smashed into a Toyota in Bushwick. The crash killed Hayden Wallace and injured three others. The driver fled, leaving chaos behind. Police tracked him for over a year. Charges stack up, but the loss remains.

NY Daily News (March 8, 2025) reports that Christopher Seabrook, 28, was arrested after a deadly hit-and-run in Bushwick, Brooklyn. Seabrook had been out on bail for a previous crash involving police. On January 8, 2024, he crashed into a Toyota, killing Hayden Wallace and injuring three others. Seabrook fled the scene, abandoning his vehicle. The article notes, "All accidents are useless but this one was even more useless because [Seabrook] had so many other offenses." Seabrook faces 23 charges, including manslaughter, leaving the scene, unlicensed driving, and speeding. The case highlights repeated driver offenses and questions about bail and enforcement. Police needed over a year to arrest Seabrook, who had a history of fleeing crashes and driving without a license.


4
Hanif Supports Safety Boosting Open Gangway Subway Cars

Mar 4 - MTA rolled out new open-gangway subway cars on Brooklyn’s G line. Riders can move freely between cars. Wider doors, better lighting, and safety cameras mark a shift. Council Member Shahana Hanif backed the upgrade. Riders welcomed the change. More trains coming soon.

On March 4, 2025, the MTA unveiled open-gangway R211T subway cars on the G line at Church Avenue, Brooklyn. The event, covered by amny.com, marked a milestone in subway modernization. The new cars feature open gangways, wider doors, improved lighting, digital screens, better accessibility, and enhanced safety cameras. Council Member Shahana Hanif (District 39) attended the unveiling and voiced support: "It'll make our ride as users more comfortable and efficient." MTA NYC Transit President Demetrius Crichlow called the design a unique experience, highlighting increased comfort and reliability. The R211T cars are part of the MTA's $68 billion capital plan for 2025-2029, pending state approval. Riders responded positively, noting the freedom to move and improved comfort. No formal safety analyst assessment was provided.


4
Hanif Supports Safety Boosting Open Gangway Subway Trains

Mar 4 - MTA rolled out new open gangway trains on Brooklyn’s G line. Riders now move freely between cars. Wider doors, bright lights, and cameras sharpen safety. Council Member Shahana Hanif cheered the upgrade. More trains arrive soon. The city’s subway inches forward.

On March 4, 2025, the MTA debuted its open gangway R211T trains on the G line in Brooklyn. The event, attended by Council Member Shahana Hanif (District 39), marked the first time G riders could walk end-to-end through the train. The new cars feature wider doors, improved lighting, and advanced cameras. The MTA’s summary states: 'The open gangway train design allows riders to walk freely between cars, a first for the G line, offering increased mobility throughout the train.' Hanif, present at the unveiling, said, 'It'll make our ride as users more comfortable and efficient.' The trains are part of the MTA’s $68 billion capital plan for 2025-2029. More R211T trains will join the G line in coming months. No formal safety analyst assessment was provided, but the upgrades focus on accessibility, visibility, and crowd movement—key factors for passenger safety.


3
Dump Truck Kills Pedestrian In Williamsburg

Mar 3 - A dump truck turned right on Withers Street. It struck a man crouched in the road. The driver fled. The man died at Elmhurst Hospital. Police are still investigating. Brooklyn’s streets claim more lives. The toll grows.

Gothamist reported on March 3, 2025, that a dump truck driver fatally struck a man in his 20s on Withers Street near Woodpoint Road in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. The man was 'crouched in the street to pick up food' when the northbound truck turned right and hit him, according to NYPD officials. The driver, a 49-year-old man, left the scene. No arrests have been made. The NYPD's Collision Investigation Squad is investigating. The article notes this crash followed two other recent fatal collisions in Brooklyn. The incident underscores persistent dangers for pedestrians and ongoing issues with drivers leaving crash scenes. NYPD data shows at least 10 traffic deaths in Brooklyn so far this year, matching last year’s pace.


2
Unlicensed Driver Flees Fatal Brooklyn Crash

Mar 2 - A man sped through a stop sign in Brownsville. His Mercedes hit a school bus. His passenger died. He ran from the wreck in a taxi. Police found him later. The victim’s family mourns. The street remains unchanged.

NY Daily News reported on March 2, 2025, that Tyree Epps, 32, drove a Mercedes-Benz without a license, ran a stop sign on Van Sinderen Ave, and crashed into a school bus. The article states, “After the crash, Epps hopped in a taxi and took off, leaving his 26-year-old passenger, Imani Vance, in the front seat suffering severe head trauma.” Epps faces charges of manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, leaving the scene, and unlicensed driving. The bus driver survived. The crash exposes ongoing risks from unlicensed, reckless drivers and the persistent danger at city intersections. The victim’s family is left to grieve and organize a funeral, while the intersection remains a site of loss.


1
Bushwick Hit-And-Run Kills Passenger

Mar 1 - A Kia slammed into a Toyota on Stockholm Street. Hayden Wallace, 29, died. Two friends survived with critical wounds. The driver fled. Police arrested Christopher Seabrook. The crash left a new life cut short, a city shaken.

According to the NY Daily News (published March 1, 2025), Christopher Seabrook, 28, was arrested for the hit-and-run crash that killed Hayden Wallace, 29, in Bushwick on January 8, 2024. Seabrook allegedly crashed a Kia Sportage into a Toyota Yaris carrying Wallace and friends, then fled the scene on foot. Wallace died; two others were critically injured. The Toyota’s driver was also charged with driving without a license. Seabrook faces charges including manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, and leaving the scene. The article quotes Wallace’s aunt: “He lived life to the fullest. He was only 29 years old and lit up every room he entered.” The case highlights the deadly consequences of reckless driving and fleeing crash scenes in New York City.


27
A 6225 Carroll sponsors bill weakening speed camera enforcement, likely reducing street safety.

Feb 27 - Assembly bill A 6225 drops the speed for owner liability to seven miles over the limit. Drivers face penalties sooner. Carroll and Simone sponsor. Aimed at curbing reckless speed. Streets may get safer. No safety analyst note yet.

Assembly bill A 6225 was introduced on February 27, 2025, and is in the sponsorship stage. The bill, titled 'Relates to reducing the speed for owner liability for failure of operator to comply with certain posted maximum speed limits,' lowers the threshold for owner liability to more than seven miles per hour over the posted limit. Assembly Members Robert C. Carroll (primary sponsor, District 44) and Tony Simone (co-sponsor, District 75) back the measure. The bill seeks to hold drivers accountable at lower speeds. No safety analyst note is available yet.


27
Myrie Opposes Misguided E-Bike Registration Licensing Bill

Feb 27 - Delivery workers rallied against Hochul’s e-bike crackdown. Council weighs bills to license e-bikes, raise pay, and study conditions. DOT opposes registration. Advocates warn of criminalization. City Hall silent. Streets stay dangerous for those on foot and bike.

On February 27, 2025, the City Council considered three bills: Intro 606 (register and license all e-bikes), Intro 1133 (expand minimum wage, study delivery worker conditions), and Intro 1135 (set minimum pay for grocery delivery). Intro 606 faces opposition from DOT, which says, 'there is no evidence that registration improves safety.' The matter’s summary warns that Hochul’s plan would let NYPD enforce bike lane speed limits and reclassify heavy e-bikes as mopeds, requiring licenses and registration. Council members are split: Brad Lander supports regulation targeting app companies, not workers; Jessica Ramos and Zohran Mamdani call for better street design; Michael Blake urges targeted safety solutions and more infrastructure. Advocates like Ligia Guallpa say these measures would criminalize delivery workers and create a 'ticketing-to-deportation pipeline.' The Council press office did not comment. The debate exposes a city divided on how to protect its most vulnerable road users.